Dark matter hurricane: Measuring the S1 stream with dark matter detectors Ciaran A. J. O’Hare, Christopher McCabe, N. Wyn Evans, GyuChul Myeong, and Vasily Belokurov Phys. Rev. D 98, 103006 – Published 7 November 2018 https://journals.aps.org/prd/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevD.98.103006 Dark Matter Blowing Like a Hurricane November 7, 2018 The dark matter in our stellar neighborhood may be moving at high speed, which might produce a signature that future dark matter searches could detect. Synopsis figure C. O'Hare; NASA/Jon Lomberg The cosmic weather forecast calls for strong dark matter winds in our region of the Galaxy. The prediction is based on a new study of a nearby collection of stars that are all moving in the same direction. This so-called S1 stream is believed to be the remnant of a dwarf galaxy that was swallowed by the Milky Way billions of years ago. The dark matter from this long-gone galaxy may be blowing past us at roughly 500 km/s, according to the study’s authors. Such a “dark matter hurricane” might leave a detectable imprint in data from dark matter searches.
The S1 stream was identified last year in an ongoing billion-star survey by the Gaia satellite. This is not the first stellar stream—in fact, astronomers have previously detected around 30 of these moving throngs in our Galaxy. The accepted understanding is that each of these streams is the debris of a small galaxy that crashed into the Milky Way. The unique interest in S1 stems from the fact that its path crosses that of the Sun. Ciaran O'Hare from the University of Zaragoza, Spain, and colleagues calculated the effect of S1 on the dark matter in our region. The team considered different models for the density and distribution of the inflowing dark matter from the S1 progenitor galaxy. They then predicted possible signatures of this fast-moving population in searches for dark matter. Current detectors looking for weakly interacting massive particles (WIMPs)—one widely discussed form of dark matter—probably won’t see any effect from S1, but future WIMP detectors might. The chances are better for axion detectors, as the energy spectrum from axionic dark matter should exhibit a broad bump with an additional narrow peak if the S1 hurricane is truly buffeting our shores. This research is published in Physical Review D. –Michael Schirber Michael Schirber is a Corresponding Editor for Physics based in Lyon, France. https://physics.aps.org/synopsis-for/10.1103/PhysRevD.98.103006
A dark matter hurricane is headed our way By Don Lincoln Updated 0544 GMT (1344 HKT) November 20, 2018 exp GPS 0528 GREENE Dark Matter_00010401 SNL Carell The Office reboot false tease vpx_00005023.jpg 'The Office' cast teases audience on 'SNL' Amanda Knox engaged to longtime boyfriend jeff rohrer former nfl player same sex marriage newday vpx_00005119 Ex-NFL player on same-sex marriage to partner colorblind deputy glasses newsource orig vpx_00000619 These glasses help man see 'a different world' LOS ANGELES, CA - OCTOBER 10: Actress Kim Porter attends the premiere screening of Amazon Original Special 'An American Girl Story - Melody 1963: Love Has To Win' at Pacific Theatres at The Grove on October 10, 2016 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Emma McIntyre/Getty Images) Actress Kim Porter dies at 47 David Hockney painting sells for $90M, smashing auction records Radar data of the Hiawatha crater taken in May 2016 is shown here. A blue arrow points to the central peak of the crater. Scientists find huge meteor crater under Greenland's ice Leukemia survivor Miles, 5, dressed as BatKid, runs the bases as part of a Make-A-Wish foundation fulfillment at AT&T Park November 15, 2013 in San Francisco. The Make-A-Wish Greater Bay Area foundation turned the city into Gotham City for Miles by creating a day-long event bringing his wish to be BatKid to life. 'Batkid' is now cancer-free exp GPS 0528 GREENE Dark Matter_00010401.jpgNow Playing Brian Greene sheds light on dark matter Dior, Jennifer Lawrence face backlash over ad US President Donald Trump (C) looks on with Governor of California Jerry Brown (R) and Lieutenant Governor of California, Gavin Newsom, as they view damage from wildfires in Paradise, California on November 17, 2018. - President Donald Trump arrived in California to meet with officials, victims and the "unbelievably brave" firefighters there, as more than 1,000 people remain listed as missing in the worst-ever wildfire to hit the US state. (Photo by SAUL LOEB / AFP) (Photo credit should read SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images) Internet rakes Trump's solution to wildfires CHRIS WATTS SENTENCING - LIVE TALKBACK WITH POLO SANDOVAL BOB BARKER BACK IN THE HOSPITAL BIZ: PFIZER TO RAISE DRUG PRICES BIZ: GM BUYOUTS POP NEWS: EMILY BLUNT SINGS WITH BACKSTREET BOYS ON ELLEN POP NEWS: MAN MAKES PORTRAIT OF "THE ROCK" WITH RUBIK CUBES MOUSEPAD WARMERS HEADLINES: EL CHAPO TRIAL RESUMES TODAY HEADLINES: MARILYN MONROE'S GOLDEN GLOBE SELLS FOR $250K GO FUND ME SCAM: WOMAN ACCUSED SAYS SHE WAS DUPED ADENOVIRUS: 11TH DEATH - DR. SANJAY GUPTA LOOKLIVE PKG FL: COPS PULL OVER CARS FOR NOT STOPPING FOR SCHOOL BUS - VIDEO GOES VIRAL IL: ELEVATOR PLUNGES 84-FLOORS MA: TOWN PREPARES FOR OPENING OF POT STORE SNOOP DOGG TO RECEIVE HOLLYWOOD WALK OF FAME STAR TODAY SPORTS: STEELERS RALLY PAST JAGS SPORTS: WARRIORS LOSE 3RD STRAIGHT BIZ: BLACK FRIDAY: SMALLER TV'S Emily Blunt faces fear with Backstreet Boys Justin Dior Combs, Sean "Diddy" Combs, Kim Porter, D'Lila Star Combs, Jessie James Combs, Quincy Brown, Al B. Sure! and Christian Casey Combs attend "The Holiday Calendar" Special Screening Los Angeles at NETFLIX Icon Building on October 30, 2018 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Charley Gallay/Getty Images for Netflix) Kim Porter's family shares conversation with Diddy WASHINGTON, DC - NOVEMBER 17: Former First Lady Michelle Obama discusses her new book "Becoming" at Capital One Arena on November 17, 2018 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Paul Morigi/Getty Images) Watch Obama surprise Michelle on stage Steve Carell as Jeff Bezos mocks Trump on 'SNL' joe biden adopts rescue dog named major orig ec_00000923 Joe Biden's new BFF? A rescue dog named Major SNL Carell The Office reboot false tease vpx_00005023.jpg 'The Office' cast teases audience on 'SNL' Amanda Knox engaged to longtime boyfriend jeff rohrer former nfl player same sex marriage newday vpx_00005119 Ex-NFL player on same-sex marriage to partner colorblind deputy glasses newsource orig vpx_00000619 These glasses help man see 'a different world' LOS ANGELES, CA - OCTOBER 10: Actress Kim Porter attends the premiere screening of Amazon Original Special 'An American Girl Story - Melody 1963: Love Has To Win' at Pacific Theatres at The Grove on October 10, 2016 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Emma McIntyre/Getty Images) Actress Kim Porter dies at 47 David Hockney painting sells for $90M, smashing auction records Radar data of the Hiawatha crater taken in May 2016 is shown here. A blue arrow points to the central peak of the crater. Scientists find huge meteor crater under Greenland's ice Leukemia survivor Miles, 5, dressed as BatKid, runs the bases as part of a Make-A-Wish foundation fulfillment at AT&T Park November 15, 2013 in San Francisco. The Make-A-Wish Greater Bay Area foundation turned the city into Gotham City for Miles by creating a day-long event bringing his wish to be BatKid to life. 'Batkid' is now cancer-free exp GPS 0528 GREENE Dark Matter_00010401.jpg Brian Greene sheds light on dark matter Dior, Jennifer Lawrence face backlash over ad US President Donald Trump (C) looks on with Governor of California Jerry Brown (R) and Lieutenant Governor of California, Gavin Newsom, as they view damage from wildfires in Paradise, California on November 17, 2018. - President Donald Trump arrived in California to meet with officials, victims and the "unbelievably brave" firefighters there, as more than 1,000 people remain listed as missing in the worst-ever wildfire to hit the US state. (Photo by SAUL LOEB / AFP) (Photo credit should read SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images) Internet rakes Trump's solution to wildfires CHRIS WATTS SENTENCING - LIVE TALKBACK WITH POLO SANDOVAL BOB BARKER BACK IN THE HOSPITAL BIZ: PFIZER TO RAISE DRUG PRICES BIZ: GM BUYOUTS POP NEWS: EMILY BLUNT SINGS WITH BACKSTREET BOYS ON ELLEN POP NEWS: MAN MAKES PORTRAIT OF "THE ROCK" WITH RUBIK CUBES MOUSEPAD WARMERS HEADLINES: EL CHAPO TRIAL RESUMES TODAY HEADLINES: MARILYN MONROE'S GOLDEN GLOBE SELLS FOR $250K GO FUND ME SCAM: WOMAN ACCUSED SAYS SHE WAS DUPED ADENOVIRUS: 11TH DEATH - DR. SANJAY GUPTA LOOKLIVE PKG FL: COPS PULL OVER CARS FOR NOT STOPPING FOR SCHOOL BUS - VIDEO GOES VIRAL IL: ELEVATOR PLUNGES 84-FLOORS MA: TOWN PREPARES FOR OPENING OF POT STORE SNOOP DOGG TO RECEIVE HOLLYWOOD WALK OF FAME STAR TODAY SPORTS: STEELERS RALLY PAST JAGS SPORTS: WARRIORS LOSE 3RD STRAIGHT BIZ: BLACK FRIDAY: SMALLER TV'S Emily Blunt faces fear with Backstreet Boys Justin Dior Combs, Sean "Diddy" Combs, Kim Porter, D'Lila Star Combs, Jessie James Combs, Quincy Brown, Al B. Sure! and Christian Casey Combs attend "The Holiday Calendar" Special Screening Los Angeles at NETFLIX Icon Building on October 30, 2018 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Charley Gallay/Getty Images for Netflix) Kim Porter's family shares conversation with Diddy WASHINGTON, DC - NOVEMBER 17: Former First Lady Michelle Obama discusses her new book "Becoming" at Capital One Arena on November 17, 2018 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Paul Morigi/Getty Images) Watch Obama surprise Michelle on stage Steve Carell as Jeff Bezos mocks Trump on 'SNL' joe biden adopts rescue dog named major orig ec_00000923 Joe Biden's new BFF? A rescue dog named Major Don Lincoln is a senior scientist at Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory. He is the author of "The Large Hadron Collider: The Extraordinary Story of the Higgs Boson and Other Stuff That Will Blow Your Mind" and produces a series of science education videos. Follow him on Facebook. The opinions expressed in this commentary are his. View more opinion articles on CNN. (CNN)According to a recent paper, the Earth is caught directly in the crosshairs of a cosmic hurricane. A swarm of nearly 100 stars, accompanied by an even greater amount of dark matter, is aimed directly at our stellar neighborhood and there's nothing we can do to stop it; in fact, the vanguard is already upon us. This sounds like a perfect summer blockbuster movie, starring The Rock and Chris Pratt, or maybe Scarlett Johansson and Charlize Theron. Don Lincoln Don Lincoln Except this is for real. But is it a danger? Well, actually, no. Not at all. But it's potentially incredibly fascinating, with lots of interesting scientific interconnections. So, what is really going on? The story starts last April, when the Gaia satellite announced the locations and trajectories of 2 billion stars in the vicinity of the Milky Way surrounding our sun. They released the data to the public. Scientists were then able to look at the data set to see if they could spot anything peculiar. In galaxies like the Milky Way, the most common behavior is that the stars orbit the center of the galaxy in a manner broadly similar to the planets orbiting our sun. However, there are some stars that exhibit unusual motion. About a year ago, astronomers identified some "stellar streams" passing through our celestial neighborhood. One of them, called S1 (for stream 1), consists of nearly 100 stars of similar age and composition, orbiting the Milky Way in a direction exactly opposite that of normal stars. It's kind of like a handful of cars driving the wrong way down the highway, except with a much greater distance between them and with no likelihood of a collision. These stars are spread out over a few thousand light years and they will pass through the solar system's neighborhood over the course of a few million years. Something is wrong with dark matter Something is wrong with dark matter Astronomers identified S1 as being part of the remnants of a dwarf galaxy that collided with the Milky Way and was consumed in an epic episode of cosmic cannibalism. Dwarf galaxies are very small, typically about 1% the mass of the Milky Way. They can orbit larger galaxies and collide with the bigger galaxy, adding their mass to the parent. This is what appears to have happened in the case of S1, although the process has taken probably a billion years. Dwarf galaxies often have a disproportionately large fraction of dark matter. Dark matter is a hypothetical and still-undiscovered form of matter that interacts only gravitationally. Scientists have proposed its existence to explain many astronomical mysteries, for example the observation that most galaxies rotate faster than can be explained by the known laws of physics and the stars and gas of which they are composed. While dark matter has not yet been observed, hypothesizing its existence is the simplest and most economical explanation for myriad astronomical mysteries. Averaged over the entire universe, dark matter is thought to be five times more prevalent than the ordinary mass of stars and gas and planets. In dwarf galaxies, the fraction of dark matter is often higher. In Fornax, a well-studied dwarf galaxy orbiting the Milky Way, researchers estimate that the dark matter is between 10 and 100 times greater than the mass found in its stars. If that number holds for S1, the dark matter of the S1 stream is passing through the Earth at a much higher velocity than the more ordinary dark matter that orbits the Milky Way -- about twice as fast. It is thought that S1 dark matter is flying through the solar system at a speed of about 550 km/s, or about 1.2 million mph. While these numbers are impressive, they are misleading. Dark matter, if it exists, is extremely diffuse and it will have no discernible effect on the solar system. The mystery of the early universe's enormous black hole The mystery of the early universe's enormous black hole Because dark matter hasn't been observed yet, these velocity numbers are speculative, although they are strongly supported by a very large body of evidence. However, the prospect of high velocity dark matter flying through the Earth has suggested an opportunity to detect it. In a paper in the prestigious journal Physical Review D, researcher Ciaran O'Hare and his collaborators calculated the possibilities of discovering dark matter using both existing and proposed dark matter detectors. They considered two varieties of dark matter particles: a very heavy kind called a WIMP (weakly interacting massive particle) and a very light kind called an axion. Because the ultimate nature of dark matter is not known, it is important to be open to all possibilities. They found that the detectors they evaluated could find WIMPs for certain ranges of the particle mass. However, when they looked at the axion possibility, it appeared the prospects were even better. Because of its light mass and the manner in which an axion would interact with the detector, the apparatus simply has a better chance of seeing the axion. (If axions exist, of course.) Experiments with names like ADMX, MADMAX and ABRACADABRA are able or will be able to search for the signatures of dark matter proposed in the recent paper. They consist of technologies that are designed to interact with axions in a strong magnetic field and convert them to ordinary microwaves or radio waves that can be easily detected. For more opinion... Sign up for our new newsletter. Join us on Twitter and Facebook It's important to remember that the S1 stream poses no credible threat to the Earth and humanity. There is no need for an action hero to save us. However, the synergy of science is staggering. A careful catalog of nearby stars has opened the prospect of a better possibility of finding and identifying dark matter, which is one of the great unanswered mysteries of modern physics. It's an amazing time we live in, in which we can study such things. I'm excited. https://edition.cnn.com/2018/11/19/opinions/dark-matter-hurricane-headed-our-way-lincoln-opinion/index.html
|